By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Karvaan IndiaKarvaan India
  • Home
  • Read
    • High Five
    • Politics
    • Society
    • Heritage
    • Culture
    • Others
  • Watch
    • High Five
    • Politics
    • Society
    • Heritage
    • Culture
    • Others
  • Listen
  • SDGs
    • Mental Health
    • Gender
    • Clean Water & Sanitation
    • Education
    • Partnership for Goals
  • Café Karvaan
    • Events
    • Co-working
    • Speakers
  • Bookmarks
Reading: India’s encounters with secular v/s anti-secular rhetoric
Share
Notification Show More
Latest News
Savarkar, Bulbul and the Frog
Essays Read Read Essays
Hindu Crisis, Muslim Cost
Politics
Delhi February 2020: Riot or Pogrom?
Watch
[Video] 5 Independence Slogans coined by Muslims
Watch
[Video] Aaghaz e Nau | Tanzil Rahman
Watch
Aa
Karvaan IndiaKarvaan India
Aa
  • Read
  • Watch
  • Listen
  • SDGs
  • Café Karvaan
  • My Bookmarks
  • Topics
    • Read
    • Watch
    • Listen
  • Quick Links
  • Bookmarks
    • Customize Interests
    • My Bookmarks
Follow US
© 2023 Karvaan India. All Rights Reserved.
Karvaan India > Story > Read > Politics > India’s encounters with secular v/s anti-secular rhetoric
MagazinePolitics

India’s encounters with secular v/s anti-secular rhetoric

jahfer
Last updated: 2020/06/29 at 8:24 PM
jahfer 3 years ago
Share
SHARE

Ideological adherence to Hindutva premised on Brahmanical dominance is the rule of law that has seemingly been the prelude to an officially ethnic state or de jure Hindu state. In such a nation, Bahujan bodies are being dominated on a daily basis where nationalism has always been a construction of the mainstream that identifies itself as the essential core of the nation. In other words, it is the mainstream which defines the ‘soul’, ‘natural’ or ‘integral’ part of the land.

Often, on the question of citizenship, the idea of citizens v/s people is deployed. Further elaborating, Dipankar Gupta writes: “The tension is between citizens and people. Under nationalism, being “a people” means more than an aggregation of citizens. In a liberal democracy, however, it is not the people but citizens that take precedence.” As any decolonized nation-state, India too had to choose either the memories of blood and soil or the national identity based on citizenship. Although the latter was chosen, the postcolonial experience of roughly seven decades shows the majoritarian mobilization against the citizens by the people whose exclusive right over the holy land is asserted right from the birth of nationalism in the subcontinent. Whatever the liberal promises that had been made to the citizens appeared to have become invisible or made to disappear from the public conscience. 

India as a nation-state ought to be seen through the paradoxes of gross poverty existing together with democracy, of diversity with the liberal constitution, and anarchy with polity. From this premise, the argument over secularism also appears to have some food for thought. 

Nehruvian secularism, along with its shortcomings, determined the postcolonial reality to an extent. Though secular, it is under his leadership the Hindu Code Bill was enacted which expanded the legal notion of being a Hindu. Anyone who doesn’t belong to Christianity, Islam, Judaism and Zoroastrianism, is deemed to have been included in the definition of Hindu. Similarly, the Presidential Order of 1950 continues to hold that “no person who professes a religion different from the Hindu [the Sikh or the Buddhist] religion shall be deemed to be a member of a Scheduled Caste.” Hence, it would be a dramatic misreading that the Nehruvian secularism has had a rupture with the traditional society in which religious affiliation is the primary manifestation of social identity. 

There have been attempts to carve out an anti-secular manifesto to counter the shortcomings of Nehruvian secularism. Gurharpal Singh observes: “While many things divide the anti-secularists, they share two common characteristics: most are neo Gandhians; secondly, and far more importantly they occupy leading positions in the charmed circles of postcolonial theory.” 

During the 1980s, the Hindutva organizations had gained the upper hand among the middle classes across Hindu society. Public Intellectuals, at the time, argued for an alternative method to combat the rise of Hindutva in the polity by adopting an approach of religious tolerance deriving mainly from India’s indigenous syncretic tradition. Ashish Nandy, who then was a leading advocate of the same, called for serious consideration as to how diversity could be politically managed. 

Singh further argued that some had even taken the task to reproduce the orientalist construction of Hinduism, its inclusivist interpretations, and tolerance from Nandy’s thought. As Peter van der Veer noted in his book Religious Nationalism: Hindus and Muslims in India, tolerance is an inadequate term to define Hindu inclusivism which essentially is a form of hierarchical relativism. 

“An important underlying concept here is that of hierarchy. The many gods and paths” he writes “are manifestations of the One who is formless, but some of these manifestations are higher than others (p, 68).” Precisely, the idea behind reclaiming the syncretic tradition is that of accommodating the “inferior beings”.

The question that needs to be repeatedly asked is, in fact about the compliance and conformity within the thoughts of secular liberals as well as its syncretic critics. Interestingly but not surprisingly, both sides are being occupied by Savarnas who mistakenly believe that they have been making a seriously radical proposition foreseeing fundamental changes in the polity.

Even if Bahujans are being accommodated under either of these Savarna categories, the inherently hierarchical social order supersedes at any cost. Like the Gandhian search for inter-religious truth lacked appeal amongst Muslims and lower castes during the colonial period, neo-Gandhians” religious tolerance’ has hardly been compassionate.

Apart from the conventional notions of democracy and secularism, a serious problematization of the same is indeed necessary. At least for the Bahujans, who vaguely constitute the lion’s share of the population across religious communities, it is a struggle to reclaim the public space with slogans that matter to them, to demand equitable distribution of state resources, to become economically self-reliant, and also to live, of course, with dignity.

You Might Also Like

Hindu Crisis, Muslim Cost

Oversights and Omissions: Response to Urvashi Butalias Indian Express Article

Bihar Election: Diary of a First Time Voter

Hindu Sena does it again: Yajna for Trumps re-election

Will rather retire than joining hands with BJP: BSP chief Mayawati

TAGGED: Anti-Secular, Bahujan, Dipankargupta, Hinducodebill, Hindustate, Indiam Nationalism, Presendentialorder, Secular
jahfer June 29, 2020
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
Previous Article Fear in Kashmir as thousands get domicile certificates: Al Jazeera reports
Next Article MP Police now books lawyer who alleged being beaten up for looking alike Muslim

Follow US

Find US on Social Medias
Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe
newsletter featurednewsletter featured

Subscribe Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

Most Popular

[Video] 5 Independence Slogans coined by Muslims
4 years ago
India’s government is better at curbing critics than COVID-19- The Economist
3 years ago
Abbas Says Security Cooperation to End, Raising Stakes for Israeli Annexation- NYT
3 years ago
Sadhvi Pragya does it again, calls Godse a ‘ Deshbhakt’
3 years ago

Karvaan India is a new-age digital magazine that intends to celebrate diversity through storytelling centred around socially and economically marginalised people.

  • Join Us
  • Member Login
  • FAQs
  • Refund policy
  • Cancellation policy
  • Advertise with us
  • Newsletters
  • Support & complaint
  • Privacy policy
  • Submissions
  • About us
  • In media
  • Contact Us

© 2023. Citizens Karvaan. All Rights Reserved.

Join Us!

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news, podcasts etc..

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?