Anti-CAA protests provoked disaffection against India: Delhi court

Credits: The Economic Times

Asif Iqbal Tanha of Jamia Millia Islamia, charged under Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA) in Northeast Delhi riots conspiracy case, has been refused bail for the second time. A Delhi court refused bail to the student, saying “vociferous agitation in the guise of Citizen Amendment Bill coupled with other activities of violence would show it was meant to cause or intended to cause disaffection against India”.

Delhi police has accused Tanha of conspiring with former JNU student Umar Khalid and Sharjeel Imam to “overthrow the government” by blocking the roads in Muslim-dominant areas. Police have also alleged that he used fake documents to buy a mobile phone SIM which was used in the riots. This SIM was allegedly provided to another Jamia student and co-accused Safoora Zargar to organise further protests.

While Tanha’s lawyer Siddharth Aggarwal argued that organisations that coordinated the protests such as Jamia Coordination Committee or Student’s Islamic Organisation, are not terrorist organisations under UAPA, Additional Sessions Judge Amitabh Rawat said, “Acts which threaten the unity and integrity of India, …causing social disharmony and creating terror in any section of the people, by making them feel surrounded resulting in violence, is also a terrorist act.” Although, ASJ Rawat agreed that these groups were not proscribed under UAPA, but also added, “we have to understand terrorist activity” as per Section 15 (“Terrorist Act”) of the Act.

“…The entire conspiracy beginning from December 2019 of intentionally blocking roads to cause inconvenience and causing disrupting of the supplies of services… resulting in violence with various means and then leading to February incident with the focus being targeted blocking of roads at mixed population areas and creating panic and attack on police personnel with facade of women protesters in front and leading to riots would be covered by the definition of terrorist act,” the order stated.

Tanha’s contention that he had no role in raising funds for the riots is misplaced by the court, as other accused in the case have been alleged to have carried out this part.

“Conspiracy has to be read as a whole and not piecemeal. Moreover, the question of presence of accused at the site in North-East Delhi at the time of riots is not a sine qua non for a conspiracy case. Hence, the provisions of UAPA have been rightly invoked in the present case,” the court said.

While disclosure statements had no meaning according to the court, the statements made by protected witnesses however, have “sufficient incriminating material” against Tanha.

ASJ Rawat stressed “in unequivocal terms that there is freedom to protest available to all the citizens of the country but that is subject to reasonable restrictions. There is also no manner of doubt that every citizen can hold an opinion about any legislation which they construe as unfair in their understanding”, and all citizens have “the right to protest against any law”.

However, “What actually has to be seen in the context of the present case is whether there was a conspiracy which led to riots under the guise of protest against CAA or not, in terms of the contents of the chargesheet.”

Independent Press is under threat

We believe that if we owe an explanation to anyone, it’s our readers. We make the powerful accountable to this democracy and remain answerable to only our readers. This becomes possible only with a little contribution from you. Consider making a small donation today and help us remain a free, fair and vibrant democracy watchdog.


Edit Desk

Author: Edit Desk

Karvaan India is an online journal of politics, culture, heritage, monuments and people. We initiate conversation around the following themes with an intent to question traditional mindsets, popular discourses and initiate meaningful debates around it.
Written By
More from Edit Desk

Five images on how Indian media promotes Islamophobia

There have been multiple reports and essays on how a section of...
Read More